Master's Thesis

Framing Vis - The Effect of Personality on the Framing Bias in Information Visualization

Alexandra Santos Maroco — 2022

Key information

Authors:

Alexandra Santos Maroco (Alexandra Santos Maroco)

Supervisors:

Daniel Jorge Viegas Gonçalves (Daniel Jorge Viegas Gonçalves); Sandra Pereira Gama (Sandra Pereira Gama)

Published in

June 22, 2022

Abstract

Undergoing complex cognitive thinking under uncertainty, individuals' judgments and decisions might rely on unconscious individual heuristics. These tend to suffer systematic deviations from rationality, designated as cognitive biases. The framing effect is a cognitive bias, consisting of the alteration of preference or behaviour under different framings of the same information. Recent research in the information visualization field has tackled how human rationale limitations affect visualization-supported decision-making. However, there is such a small body of evidence that it offers little guidance to practitioners. This study explores the framing effect in an information visualization context by depicting the decision problem of Tversky and Kahneman with visual encodings. Additionally, it delves into the influence of neuroticism within such an effect. This personality trait reflects one's tendency to feel negative emotions. We conducted user tests N = 91, collecting personality data alongside user interaction metrics and the decision-making process between a set of options under different framing contexts. Our findings suggest that visualization helps mitigate the framing effect for most of the experiment sample. Moreover, our results reveal a general lack of significance from the neuroticism trait in such an effect. We believe that developing cognitive bias-aware decision support systems is of utmost importance to leverage the full potential of information visualization and make it widely available to jobs where visualization-supported decisions are critical.

Publication details

Authors in the community:

Supervisors of this institution:

Fields of Science and Technology (FOS)

electrical-engineering-electronic-engineering-information-engineering - Electrical engineering, electronic engineering, information engineering

Publication language (ISO code)

eng - English

Rights type:

Embargo lifted

Date available:

May 1, 2023

Institution name

Instituto Superior Técnico